Archive for November, 2009

MERSEYSLIDE

Friday, November 27th, 2009

On the eve of the first Merseyside ‘Derby’ of the season, it is perhaps inevitable to reminisce about the ‘glory years’. The 60’s, 70’s and most particularly in the 80’s our city’s football clubs dominated the English game with some aplomb. There were regular Liverpool vs. Everton Wembley occasions. How we laughed as we sang in unison ‘Are you watching Manchester…’ before breaking into a raucous chant of ‘Merseyside, Mesrseyside, Merseyside’.

Unfortunately the 90’s were not so kind to our clubs, and though the start of twenty first century has seen an improvement, this season has been awful for Blues and Reds alike.

Liverpool’s elimination from the Champions League this week will cost them an estimated £30 million. Already struggling to finance the strengthening of the squad, Liverpool’s big fear now must be a failure to qualify for next years Champions League.

With other Premier League teams, most notably Manchester City, investing heavily in their squad, the unthinkable may well happen. The financial cost to both Liverpool Football Club, and to the city were that to happen, would be huge.

Despite planning permission being granted some years ago for the building of a ‘new Anfield’ at Stanley Park, the economic downturn has seen those plans shelved for the foreseeable future. That may be reasonable for the Football Club; but is it fair to the residents of Walton, who live in an area that is in desperate need of regeneration.

Across the park, and Everton’s week both on and off the field has been dreadful. Defeat at Hull City leaves the club just four points above the relegation zone. As the team were going down to defeat at the KC Stadium, news was breaking that the government had rejected Everton’s proposal to develop a new stadia in Kirkby.

The state of Everton’s finances is well documented, and in the absence of a new investor taking over the Goodison outfit anytime soon, it is difficult to see where the money is coming from to add players to an injury plagued squad in January, let alone have the financial muscle to produce a fresh plan for a new ground.

In the background, England is putting together its bid to host the 2018 World Cup Finals. Can anyone seriously suggest that either Goodison Park or Anfield are fit for purpose venues for that competition?

The ground share option is once again being mooted. In business terms, it makes good sense. Everton appear open to discussion, Liverpool not so keen. Tribalism may well get in the way of any such proposal.

But, with football such a key economic and cultural asset in the city, the council has a duty to at least initiate a discussion between both parties. Indeed, they have a responsibility to the residents of Walton at the very least, to have a timetable of redevelopment in place sooner rather than later; and they should not be shy in pushing LFC for genuine commitments in that regard.

One final point on the Kirkby issue. We keep being told by our political leaders that there is greater collaboration and co-operation across the city region. The evidence would suggest otherwise. There is not one cross border sub- regional project that has been successfully delivered. Shameful is the politest word to describe such failure.

WILL THE TORIES THROW IT AWAY?

Friday, November 27th, 2009

A General Election will take place in the summer of 2010, and up until very recently the smart money has been on a Conservative victory. However, recent wobbles by the Tory leadership, followed by several polls suggesting that the result will be far closer than previously thought, has seen pundits predicting a ‘hung parliament’ as the more likely outcome. That, in my opinion, would be a disaster for the country. However, if David Cameron and Co continues to feel it necessary to comment on any and every issue whenever a microphone is pushed in their face then they could yet grasp defeat from the jaws of victory. The more they say, the less people like them.

Labour’s problem is that Gordon Brown is as popular as Jedward! However good a Chancellor he was; and indeed however well he has handled the recession, Brown just does not have the ‘X’ Factor that voters want nowadays.

The opposition’s biggest fear will be that Labour persuades Gordon to fall on his sword early in the New Year, and replaces him with a more likeable character – most likely the current Home Secretary Alan Johnson.

That ‘dream scenario’ for Labour strategists can only happen with Brown’s agreement. The one thing we know about the Prime Minister is that he is extremely stubborn. He waited a long time for the keys to number ten. I don’t think he will relinquish them unless and until the British electorate tell him its time to go.

The ‘hung parliament’ outcome is the Liberal Democrats ‘dream scenario’. Nick Clegg’s outfit can boast an articulate and impressive economic commentator in Vince Cable-though scrutiny of some of his past pronouncements reveals that he is not the financial genius some would have us believe.

For their co-operation in a newly elected hung parliament, the Lib Dems would likely demand of a Tory or Labour leader a committent to Proportional Representation. What else they stand for is difficult to know, given the major inconsistencies that exist across the range of policy areas that they have commented on.

The ‘nightmare scenario’ for all of us would be a repeat of this years election results that gave the BNP representation in the European Parliament. Surely, we will not elect this despicable body to the House of Commons.

Six months out from the election, one thing is clear. It’s not as cut and dried for the Tories as it looked following the political conference season in the autumn. Throw into the mix a probable Live TV Leaders debate, and it could be the closest General Election we have witnessed since 1974.

THEY DON’T KNOW WHAT THEY’RE DOING

Friday, November 20th, 2009

The future of the National Football Museum was supposed to be decided upon at a meeting of Trustees yesterday.

Having read a number of statements, including the National Football Museums official Press Release, I have to say that the outcome of the meeting is utter and total confusion.

We are told that the Preston site will remain open until the Guild Year, 2012, whilst the necessary refurbishment of Urbis in Manchester takes place; but that a ‘duel site’ option will be considered “if the necessary funds” can be identified.

Lancashire County Council are said to be considering legal action, whilst the Leader of Preston City Council has described the decision as ‘putting two fingers up to the people of Preston’.

Meanwhile, Preston MP Mark Hendrick suggests that the Lancashire consortium of the County and City Councils, and UCLan should continue to discuss the future options – which presumably includes the two site solution.

Overall then, a right dogs dinner. I’m sure that football supporters would be chanting ‘You Don’t Know What You’re Doing’ at the Board of Trustees if they were given an opportunity to do so.

Whatever the final conclusion of this saga – and it’s got a fair way to go yet in my view – there surely needs to be a vote of no confidence in the existing Trustees, and the Chairman of the Board shown a red card at the earliest opportunity.

CITY THINKING

Friday, November 13th, 2009

In some places Preston is referred to as the North West’s third city. At Downtown, we always brand Preston as the UK’s newest city. But for many, both locally, regionally and most certainly nationally, Preston is more often than not thought of as a town. A big town, granted. But a town, nevertheless.

Despite winning city status almost a decade ago, we haven’t done much with it. And in the absence of any big ideas, it is little wonder that Prestonians have failed to get that ‘city feeling’. And if the locals don’t think Preston is a city, why would anyone else?

With this in mind, along with the increasing scepticism about the ability of the powers that be to deliver a city centre regeneration blueprint that has been on the table for almost a decade, DPIB alongside our marketing partners Freshfield, sponsors Moore & Smalley and UCLan, and other interested members, have come together to launch a ‘City Thinking’ campaign.

We will be coming up with, and presenting, a number of fresh approaches for Preston, not just in terms of its physical regeneration, but also in respect of how the city can market and promote itself more effectively; what we can do to improve the transport infrastructure; and how Preston can attract and involve itself in emerging markets, such as life sciences and the environmental agenda.

If you are interested in having a say, and you are a DPIB member, please contact me on frank.mckenna@downtownpreston.com

The objective is to produce a plan that will be fit for a city – and one that can be delivered over the next decade.

WOULD A ‘CITY REGION’ MAYOR BE BETTER?

Thursday, November 12th, 2009

There has been a long running debate in Liverpool, going back at least ten years, about the pros and cons of an Elected Mayor for the city.

This week the MP for Walton, Peter Kilfoyle, issued a report that concluded the need for a Mayor – but one that represented the whole of the Liverpool City Region.

In this scenario, the Mayor would be given the same powers that Boris Johnson enjoys in London, and would be responsible for major planning, transport, economic development and policing issues in Liverpool, Wirral, Sefton, Knowsley, St Helens and Halton.

Kilfoyle argues, with some justification that the current arrangements for city region co- operation and co- ordination do not, in any practical sense, operate effectively, citing the fall out between the Merseyside authorities over the issue of Everton Football Club’s move to Kirkby. He could also have used the Mersey tram fiasco to illustrate his point.

Kilfoyle is not the influence he once was, and he is likely to be an opposition Member this time next year. Nonetheless, he raises important issues that will need to be addressed by a future Conservative Government as they embark on the restructuring of local government structures that, in this part of the North West at least, simply do not work.

INJURED X1
It has been a relatively miserable start to the Football Season Blues and Reds alike, and it looks as though there is a long, hard winter ahead for both clubs. However, Everton, and more recently Liverpool, have been plagued by a succession of injuries, with Tim Howard the latest casualty at Goodison; and Albert Riera joining the walking wounded at Anfield on Monday night. To demonstrate the enormity of the problem, I have selected an X1 from the clubs’ injury list this term. I think you will agree, this team would give anyone a run for their money.

4-4-2 Formation
Howard – Everton
Johnson- Liverpool
Jagielka – Everton
Agger – Liverpool
Neville – Everton (Captain)

Pienaar – Everton
Gerrard – Liverpool
Arteta – Everton
Riera – Liverpool

Torres – Liverpool
Yakubu – Everton

Managed by someone decent, say David Moyes, this bunch could go far.